From England to Spain

From England to Spain
Homage to Catalonia by George Orwell.

Time spent on the battle-front, fighting alongside the POUM militia during the Spanish civil war led to the famous line of the Orwellian world — War is Peace .

If this war stops? Can peace be restored on shaken accountability? This question will always be evergreen amidst the darkest times.

The novel is a blend of personal account and historical context presenting ground realities which often remain buried under the overflowing propaganda by the least affected – journalists, bourgeoisie, etc.

Spanish civil war became all the more important by becoming a testbed for new fascist weapons of Germany and Italy, hence a rehearsal to the WW-II. On the outside, it was a fearse battle between fascist forces of Franco and the Communist popular front – comprising of PSUC, POUM, FAI-CNT, Anarchists, etc. When asking spectrum of communists factions to unite, deviation was expected and this made the battle convulated from inside — who would dominate the Spain after winning this battle? Communist party (PSUC) got the backing of Stalin's USSR and thus, the stronghold to churn-up propaganda to seize every bit of power from the trade unions and discredit the entire revolutionary uprising — fear mongering and witch hunting of trotskyists. They successfully made POUM and anarchists their targets by libelling them as a fascist decoy to destabilise the republican government of Spain and Catalin's semi autonomous government. For USSR, the civil war was critical to uphold communism and yet unite capitalist-imperialist Britian and France to support Spain's post war development by crumbling the philosophy of workers' state and demonising anarchial order.

This civil war was won by Popular front (communists) but eventually Spain came under the control of Fascists led by Franco who was backed by Hitler and Mussolini.

The communists in the initial years of the war cried for International help in the name of "revolution of workers". They were careful enough to never call it as - "fight for democracy" for the presence of this term democracy was detested back in 1914-17 and couldn't even unite the communists of other nations. Many countries extended their workers to boost the manpower against the monarchial- fascist nexus. When Orwell entered Barcelona, he was warned to not look that much bourgeois– he removed his necktie. On the contrary when he was escaping from the very same place, he was spared by the secret spies for looking like the sophisticated English breed. The same communists who cried for help in the name of revolution, soon began suppressing and even denying its occurrence to enable capital flow and upholding capitalist investors' confidence. These communists had become prisoners of Stalin's game of diplomacy. Other factions — POUM was declared illegal (Orwell served in 29th front - POUM, later he went into hiding to escape arrest as any association with POUM was seen as treachery) and CNT simply ousted later.

POUM and Anarchist did major share of fighting at the various fronts (Aragon, Huesca, etc) with limited weapons and untrained soldiers, mostly on voluntary basis. They were able to keep fascists at bay. On the other hand, Barcelona transitioned itself from egalitarian city of workers to emergence of modern bourgeoisie contributing to consumerism. The city of Barcelona was far away from the battle frontlines yet the civil guards (Assualt guards) possessed the latest weapons. At that time, many millitiamen (including Orwell) couldn't grasp the uneven gap in distribution of artillery between the border lines and the interior cities. Later, it was evident that every act was a ploy of Communist Party to suppress this revolution and limit the distribution of arms to POUM, anarchist and other independent armies of trade unions. Communist Party (PSUC) under the orders of USSR advocated for state controlled army (Popular army) to further weaken the workers and their ability to become rebels. From defeating fascist Franco, the war aimed at winning confidence of Britain and France for a bigger game ahead.

Internal turbulence was marked by differing ideologies that once coalased with one-another for uprooting monarchy, then began fighting among themselves to get their hidden agenda forward. Workers were seen as trotskyists who must be punished for the charge of serving in millitia other than PSUC. The peak of this power shifting was witnessed on 3rd May Barcelona street-fighting (which happened soon after the return of Orwell from the front line) over the control of Telephone exchange line which was under the possession of workers (POUM, CNT, anarchists) but Government ordered to seize it, that triggered mass shooting and buildings held captives. All this ended up in the favour of Government (Assault guards), however this event was of utmost importance as people and workers came to the streets for their rights. This led to delay the pace of centralisation ordeal of Government backed by USSR.

War is incomplete without propaganda. Reality is far away and at times remain undiscovered due to the sheer ignorance of influential class. Those who never been to battle front were the one who did the most shouting. Showrooms of press were bustling with propaganda that POUM was a traitor organization, on the contrary at the battle-front, POUM workers were taking the bullet alongside PSUC and Popular Army. POUM was made the villain of Barcelona shooting but even after being suppressed, POUM millitia defended the communist territory at Heusca leading to massive bloodshed and loss of their lives. Brave officers like Kopp who risked their entire careers to be in this war were then persecuted to be part of POUM– The trotskyists! The murderers! The traitors!

Battle frontline was simple for there was a clear and common enemy. But when one got entangled with lies, hatred and propaganda, then enemies became countless. Assualt guards took the duty of thought police. Any linkages with POUM was seen as intolerable to the political fabric. Catalonia became the epicenter as it was the stronghold of trade unions and their workers. Every person became an informer, raids became rampant and no-one was spared from getting arrested even on slightest of suspicion. Such was the atmosphere in the minds of populace.

On one side, the glorious side of war— marching soldiers, high end weapons, shiny uniforms— were celebrated but the gloomier side of the very same war was kept undiscussed— maimed soldiers, broken hospitals, casualties, pain and the endless sufferings. Such was the stark contrast when Orwell, who got a bullet shot near to his neck, was coming back in a crowded train to witness the masses soaked in celebration for departing young Italian soldiers dressed as gloriously as possible.

Every party had their propaganda flowing, but Communists (PSUC) had the upper hand to influence global perception and channelise foreign aid. The civil war was never meant for the Spaniards but the bigger global narrative, paving way towards the Second World War!

Propaganda is never based on facts but maligned with hidden and malicious motives. It is best achieved through Libel.

Why propaganda is solely based on libel? Only the purpose of making serious discussion impossible. It is as through in the middle of a chess tournament one competitor should suddenly begin screaming that the other guy is guilty of arson or bigamy. The point that is really at issue remains untouched. Libel settles nothing.

Some excerpts from the Novel

Every war suffers a kind of progressive degradation
Individual liberty & a truthful press are simply not compatible with military efficiency
I was not guilty of any definite act, but I was guilty of 'Trotskyism'.

Wizbeans

Wizbeans

garden